Sunnah Sessions

Picture of Sunnah Club

Sunnah Club

Cartridge or Straight Razor: The Ultimate Shaving Showdown!

Gillette Mach 3

Alright, peeps readers, today we’re diving deep into the age-old shaving conundrum: Cartridge Razors or Straight Razors. It’s a bit like comparing fast food to a gourmet meal; both will feed you, but the experience (and potential aftermath) can be vastly different.

1. Cartridge Razors: The Quick-Stop of Shaving

If cartridge razors were a movie character, they’d be James Bond – modern, sleek, and efficient, getting the job done with minimal fuss.

  • Lifespan: A cartridge typically lasts 5-7 shaves (or sometimes up to 15 if you believe some manufacturers), but it highly depends on your hair’s thickness and shaving frequency. We could reference Gillette here, but let’s be honest, it’s always best to follow the ‘when it drags, it’s a drag’ philosophy.
  • Durability: Modern cartridge razors are designed for regular use and can withstand the rigours of daily shaving. However, that cartridge needs regular replacements – which can be a little tough on the wallet.
  • Effectiveness: Cartridge razors are beginner-friendly. Their flexible heads can adjust to the curves of your face or legs, which often translates to fewer nicks and cuts. They’re the ready-to-go option when you’ve snoozed your alarm one too many times and need to get ready pronto.

2. Straight Razors: The Timeless Art of Shaving

Picture a Victorian-era gentleman, grooming with precision and dedication. That’s the aura of the straight razor.

  • Lifespan: If maintained properly, a straight razor can be a lifelong investment. We’re talking decades here, people! According to The Art of Shaving, with proper care, these bad boys can even become family heirlooms.
  • Durability: They’re made from high-quality steel, so as long as you’re not using it as a makeshift screwdriver or garden trowel (please, don’t), it’s built to last.
  • Effectiveness: Ah, the catch! The learning curve here is steep, with the emphasis on curve. It requires patience, practice, and a pinch of bravery. But once mastered, many aficionados swear by the close, clean shave it offers. Perfect for when you’re feeling a tad bit fancy and have time on your hands – or on your face.

Situation Sensitivity: Where and When to Use Which?

  • Cartridge Razor: Ideal for daily shaves, traveling (try fitting a straight razor in your carry-on; TSA will have a field day), and for those days when speed is of the essence. It’s also more forgiving for those tight spots like under the nose or the ankles. Best suited for the ‘I’ve got a meeting in 10 minutes’ scenarios.
  • Straight Razor: When you’re shaving at leisure, possibly on a weekend when you can spend time perfecting the craft. Great for facial hair, but using it on other body parts requires expertise (and possibly a spotter).

Delicate Territories: Armpits and Pubic Area

Navigating the forested realms of armpits and the intimate pubic region requires careful consideration. According to the American Academy of Dermatology (AAD), when shaving sensitive areas like the underarms and the pubic zone, it’s crucial to have a tool that minimises the risk of nicks, cuts, and razor burn. Cartridge razors, with their multiple blades and flexible heads, are often recommended for these areas because they adjust to the contours, providing a smoother and safer shave. Straight razors, while providing a close shave, require a steady hand and expertise, which can be challenging to achieve in these contoured and sensitive zones. If you’re looking to venture into the world of shaving these areas, a cartridge razor with a fresh, sharp blade is your best bet. And always remember to exfoliate gently beforehand, use ample shaving gel or cream, and shave in the direction of hair growth to reduce irritation.


While the straight razor is the seasoned pro of the shaving world, offering elegance and precision, the cartridge razor is like the quick-witted intern – fast, efficient, and ready for action.

So, which one’s for you? That’s like asking if you prefer wine or coffee. Both have their moments, places, and moods. As with all great debates (like pineapple on pizza), it often boils down to personal preference.

Remember, whether you’re a cartridge crusader or a straight-razor rocker, it’s not about the tool, but how you wield it. So, keep it sharp, folks!


  • Gillette. Razor Care and Maintenance. Gillette Official Website.
  • The Art of Shaving. The Craftsmanship & History of Straight Razors. The Art of Shaving Publication.
  • American Academy of Dermatology. Safe shaving for men and women. AAD Publications.

Share this post